• Compsodrillia Woodring, 1928
• Compsodrillia (Mammillaedrillia) Kuroda & Oyama, 1971 represented as Compsodrillia Woodring, 1928
• Compsodrillia (Mammillaedrillia) mammillata Kuroda & Oyama, 1971 represented as Compsodrillia mammillata Kuroda & Oyama, 1971
• Compsodrillia acestra (Dall, 1889)
• Compsodrillia albonodosa (P. P. Carpenter, 1857)
• Compsodrillia alcestis (Dall, 1919)
• Compsodrillia bicarinata (Shasky, 1961)
• Compsodrillia calesi Fargo, 1953 †
• Compsodrillia canna (Dall, 1889)
• Compsodrillia catherina Woodring, 1928 †
• Compsodrillia chowanensis J. A. Gardner, 1948 † accepted as Sediliopsis chowanensis (J. A. Gardner, 1948) †
• Compsodrillia disticha Bartsch, 1934
• Compsodrillia drewi (J. A. Gardner, 1948) †
• Compsodrillia duplicata (G. B. Sowerby I, 1834)
• Compsodrillia eburnea (Conrad, 1862) †
• Compsodrillia eucosmia (Dall, 1889)
• Compsodrillia excentrica (G. B. Sowerby I, 1834)
• Compsodrillia fanoa (Dall, 1927)
• Compsodrillia gonae De Jong & Coomans, 1988
• Compsodrillia gracilis J. H. McLean & Poorman, 1971
• Compsodrillia granaria (Dujardin, 1837) †
• Compsodrillia gundlachi (Dall & C. T. Simpson, 1901)
• Compsodrillia haliostrephis (Dall, 1889)
• Compsodrillia haliplexa (Dall, 1919)
• Compsodrillia jaculum (Pilsbry & H. N. Lowe, 1932)
• Compsodrillia mammillata Kuroda & Oyama, 1971
• Compsodrillia matheroni (Bellardi, 1877) †
• Compsodrillia nana Bartsch, 1934
• Compsodrillia olssoni J. H. McLean & Poorman, 1971
• Compsodrillia opaca J. H. McLean & Poorman, 1971
• Compsodrillia petersoni Bartsch, 1934
• Compsodrillia polytorta (Dall, 1881) accepted as Hindsiclava polytorta (Dall, 1881)
• Compsodrillia thestia (Dall, 1919)
• Compsodrillia torvita MacNeil, 1961 †
• Compsodrillia tristicha (Dall, 1889)
• Compsodrillia undatichorda J. H. McLean & Poorman, 1971
• Compsodrillia urceola Woodring, 1928 †